JSALSA Feature Articles

The Heroes represent system-proof quarterbacks who generate top-tier production regardless of external circumstances—whether operating without a strong run game, battling injuries in the receiving corps, or carrying games where the defense falls short. While raw QBR numbers alone might lead some to question the inclusion of Kirk Cousins (64.2 QBR) or Tyler Shough (62.4 QBR) at the tail end of the tier, their placement centers on long-term market value. Both have demonstrated ice-cold composure and high-level execution while navigating less-than-ideal team situations, making them high-upside buy targets before their market valuation catches up to their actual capability.

1. Brock Purdy (SF) — QBR: 85.8: Brock has been pretty much the most consistent quarterback throughout this season. The 13 touchdowns, two interceptions, no fumbles, bleeding about 1,186 yards of passing for about 69% completion, as well as the best QBR according to the NFL in the league right now.
2. Josh Allen (BUF) — QBR: 76.2: Josh Allen has been pretty dynamic, getting it through the air, getting it with his legs. The offense under Joe Brady is electrifying a nice rushing attack—eight rushing touchdowns to go along with nine passing touchdowns. Yes, has he fumbled the ball? Yes, has he thrown a lot of interceptions in the last few games? All of those things may be yes, but one thing that has not changed: Buffalo has an offense designed for fantasy football, 66% completion rate, 1,504 yardage.
3. Joe Burrow (CIN) — QBR: 73.5: Joe Burrow's consistency is key, being able to complete nearly 70% of his passes with 11 touchdowns and three interceptions. Yes, he has the seventh-best QBR in the league right now, but with the weapons he has around him entering Week 7, it's worth a buy to see what's going to happen—especially when looking at that schedule for the next three weeks.
4. Jared Goff (DET) — QBR: 66.2: Jared Goff is a quarterback who, even if some want to argue he doesn't belong in this "buy" category, you have to look at right now. He is in a highly dynamic, explosive offense that can score at will. The thing you have to like about Goff is his ability to run an effective offense that isn't entirely dependent on an elite running game. He has 12 touchdowns, remains the only starting quarterback without an interception, and has 1,485 yards through the air.
5. Trevor Lawrence (JAX) — QBR: 64.6: Look at the Jags; despite taking a loss, they look like a dark horse team. On paper they could be, especially based on how they played last year. They've made improvements, and Trevor Lawrence has made significant improvements. He has total, complete command of the offense. The running game, even though it's not where it needs to be, is actually a lot better than what was expected. Lawrence's play, with the exception of the red zone, has been absolutely incredible. He has 14 touchdowns to only 4 interceptions, passing for 1,480 yards on a 65% completion rate. While there are aspects of his game that still need significant improvement, considering the value of his stock at the start of the season, if you have not purchased Trevor Lawrence stock yet, now is the time to purchase it because it's going to be really expensive by the end of this season. I can see 32-40 TDs.
6. Kirk Cousins (LV) — QBR: 64.2: Kirk Cousins has actually been really, really good. He's been really consistent, even if he has struggled over the last few games. Every interception has its story—one of those interceptions came in clutch time, but overall it was just a bad play made into a great play by the defense. He's been able to lead a young Raiders offense into games that I think a lot of people believe they have no business being in. His value within the league is clearly something where a team like Indianapolis, Washington, possibly Seattle, or even Minnesota would be interested. Looking at it, he can clearly play: 1,582 yards, 14 touchdowns, five interceptions on 63% completion.
7. Tyler Shough (NO) — QBR: 62.4: Tyler Shough is really the same thing as Kirk Cousins in terms of value—and long-term value, not necessarily just this particular season. His long-term value is being "Mr. Clutch," being able to have a bad first half, not let it faze him, be a goldfish, and ball out. The last two games probably have been a struggle bus, but the overall data speaks for itself: 1,443 yards, 12 touchdowns, 5 interceptions on 65% completion going forward into the future. It would seem that the Saints found their quarterback, and if they decide not to stick with him, his value is only going up for whichever team he goes to next. If you haven't bought yet, it's time to buy now.

 This tier consists of quarterbacks whose values are already so high that they're too expensive to buy, those who need more data to properly evaluate, or those who leave you unsure whether they are simply benefiting from a dynamic run game or a heavily dependent system where they haven't had to do a lot to win games.

1. Lamar Jackson: Lamar Jackson is probably the best quarterback, but it's tough to figure out what to do with him market-wise. He has 967 yards passing, 6 touchdowns, and only 1 interception with an 81.9 QBR, notably completing a career-high 70% of his passes. In his last two games, he has only needed about 20 passing attempts per game, yet he is averaging a ridiculous 10.1 yards per attempt with just 1 rushing touchdown. He is clearly a winner and not worth selling, but the data doesn't necessarily suggest pushing chips in to buy—which feels more like a product of the offense he's in than Lamar himself. Hold and let's see how the data continues to roll in.
2. Caleb Williams: Banged up after missing some time, he came back looking like his college self going up against Atlanta. He went 30-for-36 for 305 yards and an 83% completion rate in that last game. So far across 3 games of performance, he has posted 712 yards, a 72% completion rate, 3 touchdowns, and 1 interception.
3. Dak Prescott: Dak is arguably a great quarterback, but the question becomes: is he the long-term answer for Dallas, or does he need a change of scenery? He has 1,639 yards through the air on a 66% completion rate, 10 touchdowns, and 5 interceptions. Dallas had 3 weeks of really great offense, but the last two weeks against Tampa Bay and Green Bay featured 4 interceptions from Dak and an offense that struggled to score 20 points, despite all the receiving talent available outside of the running back position.
4. Bryce Young: You could argue he belongs in the "Buy" category, but the main reason he isn't there yet is market perception and previous data—he hasn't done enough consistently for managers to push all their chips in. Selling his stock is no longer on the table; he is firmly in a hold pattern. His production is drawing comparisons to Jared Goff with 1,549 yards passing, 11 touchdowns, and only 2 interceptions. However, while Goff operates around a ~70% completion rate in a explosive downfield system, Bryce is completing ~60-62%, raising the question of whether Carolina needs to add another short slot/speedster threat to give him a reliable quick check-down option.
5. Patrick Mahomes: You should have bought Mahomes stock before the season started—that was a no-brainer. Now, his stock is at peak value and not worth buying. A lot of his success this season has come from having Kenneth Walker III in the backfield averaging a league-leading 6.6 yards per carry, which basically sets up second-and-short on every drive and takes massive pressure off the passing game. He has 1,309 passing yards, 9 touchdowns, and 3 interceptions on a 66% completion rate. Mahomes hasn't had to face many tough game scripts, throwing 30 or more times in only two contested games this year (Indianapolis and Las Vegas). If Walker gets nicked up, Mahomes has the skill set to carry the team, but until we see him have to do it, he remains a high-floor Hold.
6. C.J. Stroud: Stroud finally threw his first interception, posting 1,714 passing yards, 9 touchdowns, 1 interception, and a 65% completion rate. High passing volume has kept his QBR around the middle of the pack (12th overall at 65.6). While the offense hasn't consistently looked great—their 30-point performances came against high-scoring teams like Buffalo, Dallas, and Jacksonville—he still has 40-touchdown potential once this unit fully clicks. Re-establishing the Ohio State connection with Marvin Harrison Jr. alongside Nico Collins gives him elite weapons. He sits right on the borderline between a top-tier Sell and a Buy, making him a prime Hold while Houston irons out the offense.
7. Michael Penix Jr.: Through his first four games, Penix has logged 944 passing yards, 6 touchdowns, 1 interception, a 64% completion rate, and a 64.9 QBR (13th overall). His situation mirrors Mahomes in that he benefits immensely from an elite running back in Bijan Robinson (averaging 5.8 yards per carry). Over his last two starts, Penix completed ~58% of his passes as teams focused on keeping Bijan under 100 yards. It raises the question of whether Penix can elevate the team when the run game is contained. There isn't enough negative data to justify selling, but not enough to tell managers to buy either—firmly a Hold.
8. Matthew Stafford: Stafford has thrown for 1,794 yards, 11 touchdowns, and 6 interceptions on a 66% completion rate. Every interception has its story, but the analytical data doesn't care about context. If you own Stafford stock, hopefully you bought in early in his career; he isn't a stock worth buying right now as the Rams sit with four losses. However, Stafford has played significantly better over his last two games against Buffalo and Arizona despite the losses. The next three games will tell us if he is trending back up toward a Buy or returning to a rough downward trajectory.
9. Jordan Love: Love was able to get a win against the Dallas Cowboys last night. It was a great game for him. He has 11 touchdowns to only four interceptions on the year, putting up 1,684 passing yards, but an OMG-worthy 59% completion rate. He hasn't had Josh Jacobs fully available, but Jacobs might be back in the coming weeks. The question is whether that completion percentage can get any higher. He's had to drop back and throw more times than desired, and it's hard to tell if this volume is sustainable even with a run game, or if he is a clear buy, a clear sell, or the definitive future for Green Bay. They have a very interesting next few weeks with Carolina, Detroit, New England, and a matchup against a Minnesota team that has a very pesky, arguably best-in-class defense. The record is 4-2, but it's going to be very interesting.
10. Jalen Hurts: The offense he's in is clearly terrible. I'm not really sure whether it's worth a complete sell, especially given his blood clot issue—diagnosed with deep vein thrombosis and bilateral pulmonary emboli—which will cause him to miss the remainder of the 2026 season. He really tried to put the team on his back despite the offensive issues. Yes, he's thrown some interceptions, and while every interception has its story, at the end of the day, it still winds up on the books. The reliance on DeVonta Smith eventually showed up—Hurts posted 933 yards with three interceptions on the year at an abysmal 57% completion rate with barely a run game to support him. Outside of Smith being banged up, the wide receiver room just hasn't been 100% present. Dallas Goedert is great, but this is a quarterback I would just hold, especially after rumors that depending on what happens with this blood clot situation, it could determine his future with the Eagles. The Eagles are also starting to signal that they're going into fire-sale mode and transitioning into a different phase.
11. Jacoby Brissett: It's very interesting in Arizona. He's not a quarterback that anyone can 100% say is a buy, but he's also in a 100% serious holding pattern. More data needs to be displayed to determine where his true value lies. He has 1,328 passing yards, 9 touchdowns, and 6 interceptions with a QBR near the bottom tier of the league at 54.5. However, he maintains a 66% completion rate and really only had one bad game—the game against the Giants where he threw three interceptions. Yes, he has had other interceptions on the year, but he has very much looked the part of an NFL quarterback. An argument can even be made that he looks like a potential franchise quarterback that Arizona could probably get behind for a lot longer than expected.
12. Geno Smith: Geno has 1,336 passing yards, 7 touchdowns, and 1 interception on a 68% completion rate. He very much looks like a franchise quarterback for the Jets. It's worth noting the Jets have only lost one division game so far. New England has a 2-0 lead in the division, and Buffalo—as good as they've been—has already lost a division game. Being the most experienced quarterback in the AFC East, Geno could rally the Jets to finish second or even win the division, provided they can beat New England later down the road and win out against Buffalo and Miami. He's put up some really good numbers. It's not worth buying yet, but it's most definitely not a sell.
13. Deshaun Watson: He has undoubtedly made the chances of Shedeur Sanders playing in the NFL for Cleveland less likely unless a trade happens. He has 1,174 passing yards, 7 touchdowns, and 2 interceptions on a 63% completion rate. Why is he at the bottom of the hold list and most likely on the verge of falling into the sell category? He has an abysmal QBR hovering around 43.6, but the Browns currently have a 4-2 record. Until he plays a game where he throws three interceptions and costs them directly, he is just not going away.
14. Jameis Winston: He is just filling in until Jaxson Dart returns. While he's filling in, he has had no issue throwing 5 interceptions to go with his 7 touchdowns, completing 57% of his passes for 957 yards and a flat 40.0 QBR rating. It would be easy to put him in the sell category, but he has won two games and led his team to a tie—so there might be something there. Possibly not, but more data is probably warranted before we can conclusively say that Jameis Winston is a sell.
15. Bo Nix: I do not "Bo-elieve" that this is going to work out. I don't believe in it enough right now to officially say it's a sell, but with a 38.2 QBR, 6 touchdowns, 3 interceptions, and 1,049 passing yards, he is struggling badly. However, it's hard to completely sell a quarterback when the team is in the exact same situation as Cleveland: they are 4-2, and everything is still right in front of them to have a successful season and turn things around. But the likelihood is that it won't work out, and he is definitely trending in the direction of a sell.

These are the worst quarterbacks to own in the league right now, alongside players whose futures are highly questionable. This means they likely won't be with their current team moving forward, are prime trade candidates, or are probably looking at the bench next year.

1. Drake Maye: Drake Maye has started to back up the big talk. He has the fourth-highest QBR out of any quarterback in the league right now at 77.3, but he's thrown 7 interceptions to go with 11 touchdowns and 1,463 passing yards. If we look at how playoff teams contend for the Super Bowl in a do-or-die fashion, I'm not sure he is the long-term answer for New England, nor am I 100% confident he will be a long-term starting quarterback in the NFL—especially if the turnover bug finds him again. He is a good quarterback who, for the next six weeks, is just going to have to continue to rebuild shareholders' trust. He is ranked at the top of this category because he is the most likely to propel himself into a "Hold," but he is very far away from being an absolute "Buy." Considering how highly he was valued going into the season, managers didn't get a fair return on that purchase. Now that the season is underway, I still say sell because the value is just too high to hold through the turbulence.
2. Jayden Daniels: I wanted to wait to give him a fair evaluation. Every game he has been in, with the exception of one, has been competitive. But pretty much every game with him at quarterback features a slow start in the first half, and by the time the offense wakes up and has a resurgence in the second half, it's just too late. The injuries haven't helped his case either. He is completing 64% of his passes for 759 yards, 5 touchdowns, 0 interceptions, and a 65.3 QBR. On the last play of the 49ers game, he got sacked. It would seem his career at Washington is highly in question—arguably through no fault of his own. Out of all the quarterbacks in the NFL, his stock right now is not worth buying. Just as Brock Purdy was an absolute buy for consistently being the best, Jayden Daniels is an absolute sell right now because there's just no telling what we're going to get other than a slow offensive start.
3. Aaron Rodgers: How is a quarterback that's thrown 12 touchdowns, 5 interceptions, and 1,487 passing yards in the sell category? Well, look at his QBR rating (47.0). As much as we all love Aaron Rodgers, the nostalgia is pretty much gone. It is time to move on and get rid of the stock. If you want to keep it a little bit longer, there is a decent argument since they have Cleveland and Cincinnati coming up; if they can beat them, they have a great chance of heading back to the playoffs where anything is possible. But overall, it does not look great for Rodgers in this particular offense despite the 4-2 record. When you look at bottom-tier quarterbacks in the hold category like Deshaun Watson or Geno Smith, they are experienced quarterbacks in positions to potentially lead their teams and win their divisions. You could try to argue Rodgers into a holding pattern based on that, but overall, sell the stock now—it's not going to get any higher.
4. Malik Willis: Willis has 849 passing yards, 2 touchdowns, 4 interceptions, and a 44.0 QBR rating for a Dolphins team that has lost every single game. They have yet to play a division game, though their first one against Geno Smith and the Jets is going to be very interesting. Miami is in an interesting spot: do they want to play the quarterback sweepstakes in this upcoming draft, the Jeremiah Smith sweepstakes, or push to see if they can win the division right now? Currently, Malik Willis is just not looking like the guy. You can argue that there is a lack of wide receiver talent in that room and that De'Von Achane's injury did not help, but regardless, the facts say sell.
5. Sam Darnold: Darnold has 7 touchdowns and 7 interceptions with the 26th-worst QBR in the league right now at 41.6. He has 1,033 passing yards despite having premier talent available to him in Jaxon Smith-Njigba (who has 717 receiving yards). Yes, there is no Kenneth Walker, which would be greatly appreciated, but Darnold is turning the ball over seven times and completing just 60% of his passes. When Drew Lock won inside this system without Kenneth Walker, Lock had 4 touchdowns, completed 72% of his passes, and averaged 8.8 yards per attempt. It's time to sell because there might be a quarterback controversy brewing in Seattle in the next few weeks if they cannot play winning football—and that's going to be hard to do with the Chiefs and Bears coming up on the schedule.
6. Kyler Murray: With 2 touchdowns, 2 interceptions, and 662 passing yards on a 68% completion rate through 4 games (effectively 3 games since he got hurt in one), he holds a 41.2 QBR. The Vikings are undefeated, and Kyler has been showing he can be a game manager—much like his backup, Carson Wentz—relying on a defense that has only given up 20+ points once this season. With the Colts, Bills, and Lions coming up on the schedule, it's tough to know what will happen. Based on the information presented so far, Kyler is a sell. There is nothing to suggest that if the Detroit and Buffalo offenses are firing, Kyler is capable of being the guy to win a shootout from a QB standpoint. Putting the team on his shoulders is a no, and there will probably be a hard conversation about pivoting in a different direction at QB for Minnesota.
7. Cam Ward: Ward managed to lead the Titans to a divisional win against Indianapolis, which is great, but the overall season has been terrible. He is completing 61% of his passes with 4 touchdowns, 4 interceptions, 998 passing yards, and a 39.5 QBR. It has not been a pretty season for the Titans and Cam Ward, and getting a single win against Indianapolis doesn't change anything. The fact is, he is just a definitive sell.
8. Daniel Jones: Jones is having his worst season since his rookie year. It doesn't help that there have been injuries on the Colts, but throwing 6 interceptions to 4 touchdowns with 1,292 yards and a 38.2 QBR is not a way to respond to those injuries. It's not completely over yet—they did beat the Texans but lost to the Titans. There is hope that they can salvage the season just by being competitive in the division, but they need to get some wins. In that loss against the Titans, Jones went 22 of 42 for a 52% completion rate and threw 2 interceptions. It's hard to see the silver lining of being competitive in the division as an actual possibility. Red flags are already flying since the general manager was fired, signaling a fire sale is about to occur in Indianapolis, and Daniel Jones is probably going to be part of it.
9. Baker Mayfield: Outside of the fumbling issues, Baker Mayfield is statistically struggling: 615 passing yards (32nd), 2 touchdowns (tied for 31st), and a 37.1 QBR (32nd in the league). It's unclear what is going on at the Buccaneers outside of the fact that Mike Evans is no longer available as a receiving threat. The Buccaneers are going to be faced with a difficult decision regarding what to do with a guy they recently handed a new contract to; through the first three games of that new deal, he looks like he could be the worst quarterback in the league. Going back to the first game of the season, he did complete 83% of his passes, so there is an argument that while you should sell his stock right now, you can just wait and see how the rest of the season plays out and what the Buccaneers do in the draft.
10. Justin Herbert: It's a hard, hard sell. He has completed 59% of his passes so far this season for 1,141 yards, 5 touchdowns, and 8 interceptions with a 29.9 QBR. Some of those interceptions have come at the worst possible moments—4th quarter and clutch situations where there was still an opportunity to win or be competitive. However, there is a caveat. While his current stock is a hard sell this season, his future and macro data suggest that his overall value is actually worth more than someone like Drake Maye. An easy argument can be made that playing in a Harbaugh/run-heavy style system is just not beneficial to Justin Herbert, and a change of scenery would do him a lot of good. If you had to trade for either him or Drake Maye, you take Herbert. But strictly as of right now, his stock is just not worth holding.

The Denver Broncos secured a resilient 20–13 home victory over the Jacksonville Jaguars, staging a fourth-quarter surge that capitalized on critical mistakes in a tightly contested matchup between two talented rosters still establishing their early-season identities.  

​

Starting with the Jacksonville Jaguars, Trevor Lawrence turned in a C grade performance. Lawrence played composed, functional football through the first two and a half quarters, but his momentum evaporated late in the third quarter with a costly interception that opened the door for Denver’s comeback. Working through in-game injuries along the offensive line and in the tight end room, Lawrence struggled to establish a consistent rhythm with his perimeter targets—most notably Brian Thomas Jr., who has yet to fully explode as a primary focal point in the offense this season.

​

Furthermore, the game plan abandoned a ground attack that was actually finding traction. After Jacksonville revamped its backfield room, the rushing unit operated efficiently and averaged solid yardage per touch; leaning heavily into the run—much like Kansas City did to control Denver the week prior—would have taken pressure off Lawrence and kept Denver’s pass rush at bay. Instead, an unbalanced aerial attack and late-game passing stalls capped Lawrence at 189 yards with zero touchdowns and an interception, sealing a disappointing road loss.

​

On the other side of the ball, Bo Nix delivered a clutch B+ grade performance to carry Denver across the finish line. Operating behind a backfield committee that mirrored Jacksonville’s split production, Nix took complete command when the game tightened in the fourth quarter.

​The turning point came at the tail end of the third quarter: after Denver's defense produced a takeaway, Nix immediately seized the momentum, orchestrating back-to-back fourth-quarter scoring strikes to erase the deficit and seize a lead Denver would never relinquish. Nix completed roughly 70% of his passes for 288 yards and a touchdown, playing completely clean, turnover-free football without a fumble.

Cleveland’s 23–19 road victory over Tampa Bay was a classic conflicted triumph for Browns fans: thrilled with the win, but begrudgingly watching Deshaun Watson deliver a vintage performance that puts a literal nail in the coffin of Shedeur Sanders’ immediate starting aspirations.

​

Starting with the Cleveland Browns, Deshaun Watson turned in an undisputed A+ performance, pushing for Player of the Week consideration. Watson was nearly flawless through the air, completing 24-of-30 passes (80.0%) for 238 yards, two touchdowns, and zero interceptions (7.9 YPA, 9.9 yards per completion). With the ground game completely handcuffed—Quinshon Judkins held to just 21 yards on 12 carries—Watson put the entire offense on his back. He led the team with 22 rushing yards, extended broken plays, and played his absolute best football in the fourth quarter, converting four separate third downs on the go-ahead touchdown drive. 

From an outside perspective, this masterclass shuts down any quarterback controversy and buys Watson unquestioned security under center for the foreseeable future.

​

On the other side of the ball, Baker Mayfield and the Buccaneers had a better outing than their multi-fumble disaster in Week 1, but the offense left the door wide open. Mayfield finished 20-of-34 for 182 yards (5.4 YPA), one touchdown, and an early first-quarter interception. While Chase McLaughlin kept Tampa Bay in the game by drilling four field goals, settling for kicks instead of finishing drives in the end zone proved fatal.

​

The biggest tactical critique for Tampa Bay was abandoning a red-hot ground game. Bucky Irving ripped off 89 yards on 17 carries (5.2 YPC) as the Bucs rushed for over 130 total yards, yet the play-calling continually defaulted to low-efficiency dropbacks. Out wide, Emeka Egbuka caught a five-yard touchdown but was otherwise held in check, failing to make the dominant impact expected of Mike Evans' successor. Chris Godwin and Tez Johnson flashed chunk plays, but neither could take over the game. 

It all culminated on the final possession following a two-hour weather delay: facing fourth-and-goal from the 20-yard line with two seconds remaining, Mayfield’s end-zone shot fell incomplete for a turnover on downs. Mayfield earns a C- grade—he avoided catastrophic fumbles, but averaging barely five yards per attempt and stalling repeatedly in the red zone cost Tampa Bay the game

The Cincinnati Bengals secured an impressive 20–6 road victory over the Houston Texans, dropping Houston to 0–2 and exposing a Texans defense that many fantasy managers and analysts were sold on as the league's top unit.

​

Starting with the Houston Texans, C.J. Stroud dropped back 55 times, completing 30 passes for 353 yards (6.4 YPA, 11.8 yards per completion) with zero touchdowns and zero interceptions, while taking four sacks. Outside of Stroud's scrambles for 29 yards, there was virtually zero ground support, with the backfield held to just 18 rushing yards. 

While Dalton Schultz stepped up in a massive way in Nico Collins' absence—hauling in 12 targets for 140 yards—the rest of the receiving room was non-existent. The next two most targeted players combined for no more than three catches apiece on nine and seven targets. 

Despite the adversity and lack of a running game, Stroud is evaluated with a C grade: dropping back 55 times without manufacturing a single touchdown falls squarely on the franchise quarterback. At some point, he has to scramble, extend plays, and finish drives in the end zone himself.

​On the other side of the ball, Joe Burrow delivered an A grade performance. Burrow went 20-of-31 for 207 yards and two touchdowns without a turnover, playing poised, mistake-free football despite being sacked five times. 

Chase Brown gave Cincinnati the balanced backbone Houston lacked, churning out 80 yards on the ground to sustain drives. With both Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins active and making plays—Burrow connecting with them for over 10 yards per completion—the Bengals maximized their limited opportunities. Even though Cincinnati lost the time of possession and ran fewer total plays, their efficiency was lethal. 

The clear area of improvement for Cincinnati heading into Week 3 is starting faster: for an offense with this much elite firepower, sluggish first quarters must be eliminated.

Heartbreak for the Buccaneers as the Bengals claim a 33–27 victory, handing Baker Mayfield his first season-opening loss as Tampa Bay's starting quarterback.

Looking at Tampa Bay first, Baker’s issues weren't about raw arm talent or accuracy. He was dialed in through the air, completing nearly 83% of his passes—going 23-of-28 for 216 yards and a solid 7.7 yards per attempt—along with a score on the ground. 

However, as the quarterback and team leader, ball security is everything, which drops his grade down to a flat C. Three devastating fumbles gifted Cincinnati 17 free points—points Joe Burrow and that offense barely had to sweat for. 

The passing rhythm was clearly there, but Baker made bone-headed decisions with the football. Yes, it’s only Week 1, but coughing up the ball three times without a care in the world is backbreaking and has to be cleaned up immediately. Strip away those three turnovers, and his efficiency looked every bit like that of a top-tier quarterback.

For Joe Burrow and the Bengals, they took full advantage of the short fields provided by their defense. The defensive unit created easy scoring opportunities, and the offense capitalized efficiently. Burrow finished 25-of-35 (71.4%) for roughly 254 yards (7.3 YPA) with one interception on the day. 

The target distribution was the real surprise: 

Mike Gesicki was Burrow's most targeted weapon, followed closely by Tee Higgins. Ja'Marr Chase saw just four targets, pulling in only two catches. While it’s nice to see Gesicki integrated into the scheme early, Cincinnati needs to funnel considerably more volume toward Higgins and Chase moving forward. 

When you have a passer as lethal and pinpoint as Burrow, you want your alpha wide outs dictating the game.

Because the defense thoroughly rattled Mayfield and set up easy points, Cincinnati’s offense never truly had to empty the playbook. Burrow earns a B grade for a efficient outing where he did exactly what was required to secure the Week 1 win.

The Chicago Bears and Carolina Panthers gave us arguably the most explosive fireworks show of the week—at least until the Panthers finally ran out of ammunition in a 59–37 shootout. Despite the lopsided final score, both signal-callers played at an elite level, with Caleb Williams delivering one of the three best quarterback performances across the entire league this week.

Williams played completely within the system while still flashing undeniable superstar traits. He showed total command of the offense, gladly took checkdowns when coverage dictated, and used his legs decisively to extend drives. He looked every bit like the generational talent he was drafted to be, finishing 21-of-29 for 265 yards, two passing touchdowns, and an additional 65 yards on the ground. Averaging 9.1 yards per attempt, he operated as an efficient first-down machine. 

he backfield gave him absurd support as 

Chicago racked up nearly 300 rushing yards: D'Andre Swift crossed the century mark, Kyle Monangai broke loose for over 100 yards of his own, and Williams tacked on his 65. When you pair an unstoppable ground attack with a quarterback who balances game-manager discipline with elite playmaking electricity, you're going to win a lot of football games.

 Carolina’s defense was an absolute turnstile, so tougher tests await, but Williams earning an A+ is undeniable. The real test is whether he can maintain this sharp consistency down the stretch.

On the other side of the field, Bryce Young also looked like the former number-one overall pick he was drafted as. Despite throwing one interception, Young walks away with a strong A- grade after going toe-to-toe in a high-scoring track meet. He finished 23-of-37 for 361 yards (9.8 YPA) with a 62% completion rate, showing complete control and command in the pocket. 

Chuba Hubbard provided solid balance on the ground and flashed as a reliable outlet through the air, though the offense could have used even more rushing support to take the heat off.

Carolina's wide receiver room is still very much a work in progress, making Young's production all the more impressive. Entering a pivotal "prove-it" year where many felt his starting job was on the line, Young proved he belongs. 

Taking the loss hurts, but it's only Week 1; just like with Williams, sustained consistency is the missing ingredient for a quarterback who has historically oscillated between brilliant outings and complete duds.

The San Francisco 49ers and Los Angeles Rams kicked off the season with a Thursday Night Football showdown. Many expected a tightly contested divisional dogfight, but Brock Purdy took care of business—"Mr. Irrelevant" looking undeniably relevant in a 27–7 rout.

Starting with the Los Angeles Rams, Matthew Stafford and the offense completely sputtered. Stafford never looked in sync, finishing 15-of-25 for just 155 yards, no touchdowns, and 1  interception (6.2 yards per attempt). Given what this unit has achieved in the past, it’s too early to sound the alarm, but this was a painfully sluggish opening act. 

Defensively, the Rams have far more lingering questions to answer than on offense, as they struggled to get off the field. For Week 1, Stafford lands a C grade for a stagnant outing where the offense never found another gear.

On the other sideline, the San Francisco 49ers looked like a legitimate powerhouse contender. Even with Purdy coughing up an interception early in the second quarter, he completely outplayed Stafford. It certainly helped that San Francisco's defense bailed him out almost immediately by picking off Stafford, which Purdy promptly cashed in on the ensuing possession to engineer a scoring drive.

Purdy finished the night 25-of-34 for 205 yards, averaging around 6.0 yards per attempt. While that per-attempt figure is fairly pedestrian, it fits the rhythm-and-timing design of Kyle Shanahan's system. There is a valid argument that he needs to push the ball vertically down the stretch—especially with an embarrassment of riches featuring Mike Evans, Deebo Samuel, Demarcus Robinson, and George Kittle, alongside Christian McCaffrey in the backfield.

 San Francisco also provided stellar backfield balance, with two running backs splitting the workload for roughly 60 yards each on 24 total carries. When you control the game and distribute the football with that kind of efficiency, Purdy rightfully slots into the A tier for Week 1.

The Atlanta Falcons find themselves in a fascinating position, somewhat similar to the New Orleans Saints and the Miami Dolphins when they evaluated Drew Brees in 2006 free agency. That free agency changed the Saints forever when they took a risk on a player where medical professionals claimed there was only a 25% chance of full recovery. Today, both Tua Tagovailoa and Michael Penix Jr. have their own injury history, but both possess immense talent—and both happen to be left-handed signal-callers.

​Tua is the veteran with a career 68% completion rate, making him highly efficient. Some will point to his career interception totals, but if you look closely at the data, you’ll notice those interceptions almost always happen when he is under stress behind degraded protection. The offensive line will be key for Tua.

​Coming off a season where his interceptions spiked and he posted under 7 yards per pass for the first time since his rookie and sophomore years, he has plenty of questions to answer. Still, Atlanta got a steal obtaining his services for this upcoming year. While I don't see Tua opening as the starter, if you play fantasy football and need a premier backup quarterback who can put up heavy points when called upon, put him right at the top of your draft board.

​Michael Penix Jr. enters the year with just under 14 games under his belt and a 59% completion rate. Penix is undoubtedly talented, and it's far too early to call it quits on a first-round draft pick seen as the future of the Falcons.

​I think the Falcons are going to give him the first crack at the job. A stat line of 9 touchdowns and 3 interceptions in his 9 starts last year isn't the worst baseline for someone taking over as the guy after sitting behind a veteran. Although there is plenty of room for improvement, it's worth noting that during those starts, he vertically stretched the field 20+ yards over 26 times while throwing only three interceptions on those deep shots.

​Without a doubt, this quarterback battle between Tua and Michael Penix Jr. will be the most interesting preseason battle in the NFL. Whichever quarterback wins the job inherits a core featuring Drake London, Darnell Mooney, and Kyle Pitts, alongside a elite running back in Bijan Robinson.

​Four out of five offensive line starters are returning from a unit that gave up only 26 sacks last season. That front line will be the edge factor—especially in Tua's case if Penix either gets hurt or underperforms. Whichever quarterback stays healthy and avoids high-risk situations will ultimately win the job in Kevin Stefanski's system, but the first crack will undoubtedly be given to Michael Penix Jr.

​The Arizona Cardinals enter training camp with one of the most intriguing quarterback competitions in the NFL. It is a quarterback battle where almost any of the three contenders could step in and look good—provided they throw 20+ touchdowns and keep their interceptions under single digits.

​That baseline is actually what Jacoby Brissett delivered last year. However, that was under a completely different regime. With a new coaching staff in town—led by head coach Mike LaFleur and offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett—the entire dynamic changes. What remains clear is that the winner of this job inherits a highly talented supporting cast featuring Marvin Harrison Jr., Michael Wilson, Trey McBride, and new addition Kendrick Bourne.

​Last year, those playmakers thrived in a system that displayed their talent well, run by a quarterback who knew how to execute it. This season, Hackett brings in a new scheme with a heavier emphasis on play-action and the run game. That transition leaves the starting job as a total toss-up heading into camp.

​Jacoby Brissett took over last season after the franchise parted ways with Kyler Murray, putting together arguably the best statistical year of his NFL career. It was without a doubt his best opportunity to showcase what he can do as a starter.

​While the team struggled to a 3-14 record and Brissett only managed one win in his starts, he proved he could elevate the talent around him. He allowed his targets time to get open and delivered the ball accurately despite taking a beating behind the line. Brissett was sacked 43 times—the fifth-most sacks allowed for QBs with 12+ starts, trailing only Drake Maye.

​Holding onto the football too long is a fair criticism of Brissett, but it's worth noting the company he keeps: both the New England Patriots (who reached the Super Bowl) and the Buffalo Bills (who reached the AFC Championship) finished near the top of the league in sacks allowed. Despite playing behind a leaky line and dealing with a struggling defense, Brissett proved he has real chemistry with this receiving corps.

​Because he is a seasoned journeyman, learning Hackett's new system shouldn't phase him. The biggest question is whether the organization views him as the primary option going forward.

​Gardner Minshew enters the mix as another proven NFL journeyman and a personal fan favorite. Early reports heading into camp suggest Minshew already has a solid grasp of the offensive system Hackett wants to run.

​We know Minshew as a dynamic, high-risk playmaker who can be extremely accurate when he's in a rhythm. Looking back at his 2024 season in Las Vegas where he made nine starts, Brissett’s 2025 campaign still looks like the safer option. Minshew was sacked 29 times during that 9-game stretch in Vegas and posted a concerning turnover ratio.

​Now entering his eighth year in the league, the question is whether he can protect the football if given the opportunity. Competing against Brissett—who just received a major 2026 pay raise from the Cardinals—means Minshew faces an uphill climb. To steal the job away, Minshew will likely need an exceptional, mistake-free preseason showing.

​Carson Beck enters as the third-round rookie who could represent the future—or perhaps even prove to be the best pure passer on the roster right now. But as a rookie, he has to prove it from day one.

​Beck projects as a highly efficient game-manager. If a veteran journeyman like Brissett could look good with Harrison Jr., McBride, Wilson, and Bourne, a distributor like Beck should be able to thrive in the exact same environment.

​Because Brissett sat out during spring workouts over his contract, Beck capitalized on extra reps to get ahead in learning the system. However, his primary job in camp is beating out Minshew for the backup role. His directive in the preseason is simple: protect the football, limit mistakes, and make those elite pass-catchers look great.

​The Cardinals' quarterback room is one of the most fascinating situations in the league. You have three distinct signal-callers dropping into a weapon-rich offense, and the job will ultimately go to whoever elevates those playmakers while protecting the football. If none of the three can establish consistency, Arizona won't hesitate to look toward next year's draft—especially if the defense fails to take a step forward.

The Baltimore Ravens are coming off a highly underwhelming 2025 season. Lamar Jackson is now squarely in his prime, the reality is that the quarterback room in Baltimore is undisputed. The brief Diego Pavia competition didn't last long—and we don't even need to get into the reasons why he was waived. We are solely focused on Lamar.

​There is absolutely no quarterback controversy here. Tyler Huntley and Skylar Thompson have zero chance of taking Lamar's job. Even if Jackson were to have back-to-back underwhelming seasons, he isn't losing his spot.

​The real question is whether this offense will be more dynamic this year. It wasn't that long ago that Jackson looked unstoppable, and he is still highly capable of reaching that ceiling. However, with the heavy mileage and yardage already on his legs, leaning on the running game to make him more of a pocket passer might be the most conducive path forward.

​Jackson is very capable of shredding defenses from the pocket, but that relies on two massive variables: his supporting cast and his protection. The big question is whether the talent around him can elevate the passing game outside of Derrick Henry, Justice Hill, and Zay Flowers.

​Outside of the skill positions, the most glaring issue for the Ravens heading into the season is the offensive line. Baltimore is only returning their two tackles from last season.

​Last year, the Ravens' offensive line surrendered over 40 sacks, tying them for the 12th-worst (or 20th-best) pass protection unit in the league. That was a drastic regression from the 2024 season, where official league data ranked them as the third-best offensive line in the NFL for preventing sacks.

​However, a lot of those pass-protection numbers are directly skewed by Jackson's availability. In 2024, Lamar played 17 games and rushed for over 900 yards, using his legs to erase pressure. Compare that to 2025, where injuries limited him to 13 games and roughly 350 rushing yards. When his mobility is hampered, the offensive line is forced to hold up longer, and last year, they couldn't.

​Outside of finding secondary weapons to pair with Zay Flowers, the biggest question for the Baltimore Ravens coming into this season is simply the health of Lamar Jackson. Even if his health is just average or mediocre, and even if he only replicates the exact same season as last year with slightly better passing metrics, Lamar Jackson is still undeniably one of the top quarterbacks in the league.

​He just needs to stay healthy. And for him to stay healthy, that offensive line has to step up.